A What I Love About You journal vs a finished book
Side by side
| Darling ReasonsReasons I Love You and 28 other titles | Fill-in journalKnock Knock's What I Love About You | |
|---|---|---|
| Price in the UK | Digital £9, softcover £22, hardcover £39 | £8.54 on Amazon UK (RRP £8.95) |
| Price in the US | Digital $12, softcover $29, hardcover $49 | $10 |
| What's inside | Fifty reasons, one per page, and your dedication | 112 small pages of prompts to finish by hand |
| Who writes it | You. A writing assistant drafts from your answers, and you keep, change or rewrite every word | You, by hand |
| Pictures | The two of you, from our character builder, in four illustration styles | Printed prompts, no pictures of you |
| Size | 21.6 cm (8.5 in) square | 4.5 × 3.25 in |
| Formats | Digital, softcover or hardcover; printed books include the digital book, which opens as soon as you pay | Small hardback |
| Before printing | Read and change every word, and see your people on the cover and first few scenes. The other scenes are illustrated after you order | Not applicable |
| Reviews | Only a few so far | 4.6 from about 22,000 Amazon ratings |
| Delivery | 7 to 9 working days in the UK, free on hardcovers, and 10 to 12 working days in the US, printed near them | From stock at Amazon and bookshops |
Choose Fill-in journal if
You want the lowest price and the charm of your own handwriting, and you're sure you'll fill every page before you give it.
Choose Darling Reasons if
You'd rather not face fifty blank prompts: we draft from your answers, and you keep, change or rewrite every word. It arrives printed and illustrated, and the digital book is ready the moment you pay, for a gift that's due tomorrow. See what's inside ours, or every page of a finished book.
Where we fall short
- A journal in your own handwriting is more personal, if you finish it.
- It costs less: about £9 against our £22 softcover.
- It's sold everywhere, from Amazon to bookshops, and has about 22,000 Amazon ratings.
Questions
What is the What I Love About You book?+
Usually Knock Knock's fill-in journal: 112 small pages, about 4.5 by 3.25 inches, each with a printed prompt for you to finish by hand. There's also our finished version, What I Love About You, written from your answers and illustrated.
Is there a What I Love About You book that's already filled in?+
Yes. Ours arrives finished: fifty things you love about them in your own words, one to a page, with their name on the cover and the two of you illustrated. You read every word before it's printed.
Which is cheaper?+
The journal, at about £9 or $10. Our digital book is £9 ($12) and our softcover £22 ($29).
I'd still like to write one by hand. Where do I start?+
With a list. Our 50 reasons why I love you comes with a free printable, with pages to write your own on.
Prices and details for other books are as shown on their own websites and on Amazon on 5 November 2026, and may have changed since. Sources: Knock Knock's journal and the journal on Amazon UK. All the facts about ours are on our facts page.